Updated November 11, 2026. By John Snyder, owner, Philadelphia Master Plumber License #051593.

Direct Answer

Pipe bursting breaks the old sewer and pulls new HDPE pipe through at the same size, while CIPP lining cures a new pipe inside the old one. In Philadelphia, bursting is limited to pipe 6 inches and smaller, lining to one and two family homes, and a recorded camera survey decides which fits. [1][3]

TL;DR

One liner: In Philadelphia, the camera survey and the plumbing code, not a preference for one method, decide between pipe bursting and pipe lining.

Key Numbers

Stat What it measures Source
Gravity pipe 6 inches and smaller, same nominal size Pipe bursting size limit, building sewers Philadelphia Plumbing Code P-716.2, read Nov 3, 2026
Gravity pipe 4 inches and larger Lining size limit L&I FAQ PB_035, file posted Sep 2025
One and two family dwellings Lining building limit L&I FAQ PB_035, file posted Sep 2025
HDPE, SDR 17, ASTM F714 Bursting replacement pipe ICC CodeNotes, 2021 IPC 716, 2022
25 in-service liners, 11 cities, 5 to 34 years old CIPP field study Procedia Engineering (EPA study), 2016
50 years, and probably well beyond CIPP design life Procedia Engineering (EPA study), 2016
At least 100 years, when basic conditions are met Polyethylene gravity sewer pipe TEPPFA, Dec 2014
About 8 to 38 years in service Excavated polyethylene sewer pipe TEPPFA, Dec 2014
$50 to $200 per linear foot Open excavation This Old House, 2026
$80 to $250 per linear foot CIPP lining Angi, 2026
$60 to $200 per linear foot Pipe bursting Bob Vila, updated Jan 27, 2023
$1,949 to $6,156 Philadelphia trenchless replacement Angi, Philadelphia estimates, 2026

 

Pipe Bursting vs Pipe Lining at a Glance

In short: Bursting replaces the old pipe with HDPE at the same size, lining forms a new pipe inside it, and Philadelphia’s code limits each one.

Both are trenchless sewer repair methods, and we do both as part of our trenchless sewer repair in Philadelphia. The difference is what happens to the old pipe. Pipe bursting breaks it apart and pulls a new pipe into its place. Cured in place pipe lining (CIPP lining) leaves it in the ground and cures a new pipe inside it.

  Pipe bursting CIPP lining
What it does Breaks the old pipe outward while pulling a new pipe through it [2] Cures a resin liner inside the existing pipe
The old pipe Broken into pieces that stay in the ground Stays in place as the host pipe
The new pipe High-density polyethylene (HDPE) pipe, SDR 17 [2] A cured liner. Sectional work follows ASTM F2599 [3]
Philadelphia size limit Gravity pipe 6 inches and smaller, replaced at the same nominal size [1] Gravity pipe 4 inches and larger [3]
Lines it can be used on Building sewers and building drains [1] Building sewers serving one and two family homes [3]
Inside diameter after Same nominal size as before [1] Slightly smaller than before [2]
Openings needed One at each end of the run, for the bursting tool and the puller [2] Works from inside the existing line
Camera surveys A recorded survey before the work, and a second one approved before pressure testing [1] A recorded survey reviewed before the permit, and a second one after [3]

 

On size alone, a 4 inch building sewer at a one or two family home fits both columns. It sits at the lining minimum and under the bursting maximum [1][3]. The lining limits come from the Department of Licenses and Inspections (L&I) summary of the 2021 Philadelphia Plumbing Code [3]. What decides between the two is the condition of the pipe, and only a camera shows that.

Philadelphia Limits Pipe Bursting to Same-Size Replacement

In short: On a Philadelphia building sewer, bursting replaces gravity pipe 6 inches and smaller at the same nominal size, with an L&I permit and two recorded camera surveys.

In Philadelphia, pipe bursting can’t make your sewer bigger. The Philadelphia Plumbing Code limits bursting of a building sewer or house drain to gravity pipe 6 inches and smaller [1]. The replacement pipe “shall be of the same nominal size as the existing piping” [1]. The 2021 International Plumbing Code carries the same rule [2].

Upsizing is often sold as a reason to burst. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) fact sheet on the method says it can install a similarly sized or larger pipe, and that size for size is the most common job [5]. That describes the method. On a Philadelphia building sewer, the code sets the size.

Say you hoped to burst a 4 inch line up to 6 inches to end slow drains. Under P-716.2, the new pipe goes in at 4 inches [1]. What changes is the pipe itself: a joint-free HDPE run in place of the old one, which the International Code Council notes keeps roots out [2].

Here’s what the code asks for on a bursting job:

  1.       An L&I plumbing permit, issued only after proof that PA One Call and any other agency involved has been notified [1]. L&I’s EZ permit standard covers bursting within that size limit [4].
  2.       A recorded camera survey of the old pipe, with water run through it to show any alignment problems. The survey notes each cleanout and the depth of each connection [1].
  3.       HDPE replacement pipe, SDR 17 under ASTM F714 [2].
  4.       A second recorded survey of the new pipe, approved by L&I before the pressure test [1].

Every bursting job in the city has to follow these steps. Ours run under Philadelphia Master Plumber License #051593, held by our owner, John Snyder.

When Cured in Place Pipe Lining Is Allowed in Philadelphia

In short: L&I’s code summary allows lining on building sewers serving one and two family homes, on gravity pipe 4 inches and larger, unless the camera shows back grade, a failed wall or a full separation.

Cured in place pipe lining puts a resin-soaked liner into the old pipe and cures it hard, so a new pipe forms inside the old one. The old pipe stays in the ground as the host. In Philadelphia, L&I’s summary of the 2021 plumbing code allows lining only on building sewers that serve one and two family homes [3].

What L&I checks What the code summary says
The building One and two family dwellings only. Commercial relining is not allowed [3]
The pipe Gravity drainage piping 4 inches and larger [3]
Before the permit L&I reviews a recorded camera survey, which also verifies the property address [3]
Defects that rule it out Back grade or too little slope, complete pipe wall deterioration, or a complete separation, such as from tree root invasion or improper support [3]
After the work A second recorded survey that shows no defects. For sectional cure-in-place, the permit holder also certifies the work to L&I in writing [3]

 

That means a duplex qualifies on building type and a three unit building doesn’t. On a home that qualifies, the camera has the last word. Where the survey shows one of those defects, L&I’s code text says lining is not permitted, and the defective section has to be exposed and repaired [3].

When a line passes, we use cured in place pipe to form a new pipe inside the existing one. The yard, the sidewalk and the basement floor stay where they are.

Pipe Lining Lifespan vs a Burst HDPE Pipe

In short: CIPP has a 50-year design life backed by EPA-funded field samples, and polyethylene sewer pipe at least 100 years in an industry study. Neither is a warranty.

Pipe lining lifespan is usually given as 50 years, and burst polyethylene pipe as 100. Both are design lives from studies of pipe that was put in well. Neither one is a guarantee [6][7].

Method Lifespan figure What backs it Source
CIPP lining A 50-year design life, and probably well beyond 25 in-service liners from 11 North American cities, 5 to 34 years old, tested in a U.S. EPA retrospective study Procedia Engineering, 2016 [6]
Pipe bursting with polyethylene pipe At least 100 years for gravity sewer pipe, when basic conditions are met Polyethylene and polypropylene sewer pipe dug up after about 8 to 38 years of service TEPPFA industry study, December 2014 [7]

 

Two limits come with those numbers. The liners in the EPA study came from city sewers, not house laterals [6]. The polyethylene figure comes from a European industry report, checked by an outside reviewer, on pipe made to European standards [7].

Both studies come back to the install. The EPA researchers found the liners in excellent condition overall, and still named steps where quality control during installation should improve [6]. Philadelphia’s second camera survey, required after both lining and bursting, is the check on that work [1][3].

A design life also isn’t a warranty. Our warranty terms are written on the estimate or invoice, so ask to see them next to the method you’re quoted.

Pipe Bursting vs Pipe Lining Cost, Next to Excavation

In short: Per foot, excavation, lining and bursting overlap. The total differs by what has to be dug up and restored.

Per foot, the three methods overlap. The gap in the total comes from what has to be dug up and put back.

Method Published range per linear foot What gets dug up and restored
Open excavation $50 to $200 [10] The full length of the trench, whether that’s yard, sidewalk or basement floor
CIPP lining $80 to $250 [8] Little or none
Pipe bursting $60 to $200 [9] An opening at each end of the run

 

These are national published ranges, not our prices. This Old House notes that trenchless methods can save money on landscape restoration and property damage [10]. For Philadelphia, Angi estimates $1,949 to $6,156 for a trenchless sewer replacement, built from national averages adjusted with local price data [11].

On top of any method, a Philadelphia job adds City permits, sidewalk restoration and access work. Those drive sewer line repair cost in Philadelphia as much as the pipe does. We price every job from a written estimate after the camera inspection.

How a Camera Inspection Picks Between Trenchless Sewer Repair Methods

In short: The camera finding, matched against the code limits, points to cleaning, lining, bursting or excavation.

Before the camera goes in, nobody can say which of the trenchless sewer repair methods your line needs. After it, the code usually narrows the choice. For bursting, Philadelphia requires a recorded survey of the old pipe with water run through it, noting each cleanout and the depth of each connection [1]. For lining, L&I reviews the survey before it issues the permit [3].

What the camera shows What it points to
Roots or buildup in a pipe that’s still sound Cleaning first. The job may end with drain cleaning and sewer jetting
Cracks, leaks or root damage in a pipe that keeps its shape Lining or bursting. Lining needs a one or two family home, pipe 4 inches or larger and L&I’s review of the survey [3]. Bursting needs pipe 6 inches or smaller, replaced at the same size [1]
Back grade, too little slope, a failed pipe wall or a full separation Lining is not permitted, and the section is exposed and repaired [3]
Pipe larger than 6 inches Bursting is outside P-716 [1]
Old pipe that’s shallow, sits in rocky or sandy soil, or runs close to other utility lines Bursting gets harder. The EPA lists soil that won’t compress, shallow pipe and nearby lines as conditions that complicate it [5]
Pipe that’s collapsed, severely offset or beyond repair Excavation and full replacement

 

The camera also shows where the problem sits. The Philadelphia Water Department (PWD) makes the owner responsible for the sewer lateral in Philadelphia, from the house out to the City sewer [12]. Following that run tells you whether the trouble is under the basement floor, the sidewalk or the street, and that changes what has to be opened.

We include a free camera inspection with qualifying jetting services. Call 267-804-1824 for a camera inspection and a written estimate.

Frequently Asked Questions

In short: Bursting can’t upsize a Philadelphia building sewer, lining is limited to one and two family homes, and both need an L&I permit and two camera surveys.

Which is better, pipe bursting or pipe lining?

Neither is better by default. Bursting replaces the pipe with new HDPE at the same size, and lining forms a new pipe inside the old one [1][2]. In Philadelphia, the camera survey and the code limits for each method decide which one your line can use [1][3].

Can pipe bursting upsize a sewer line in Philadelphia?

No. The Philadelphia Plumbing Code limits bursting of a building sewer to gravity pipe 6 inches and smaller. The replacement pipe has to be the same nominal size as the old one [1].

Can a three unit or commercial building get CIPP lining in Philadelphia?

Not under L&I’s summary of the 2021 plumbing code. It allows relining and cure-in-place only on building sewers serving one and two family homes, and it doesn’t allow commercial relining [3].

How long does pipe lining last?

CIPP is designed for 50 years. An EPA-funded study of in-service liners up to 34 years old found them in excellent condition overall and expected to last their 50-year design life and probably well beyond [6]. A design life isn’t a warranty, so ask for the warranty terms in writing.

Do I need a permit for trenchless sewer repair in Philadelphia?

Yes. L&I issues a plumbing permit for the work, and for bursting it needs proof that PA One Call has been notified first [1]. For lining, L&I reviews the camera survey before it issues the permit [3]. Repairing the lateral also needs a Sewer Connection Permit from PWD [13].

How long does trenchless sewer repair take?

Often about a day. Angi says crews working from two small access holes can install or repair pipe in as little as a day [14]. It also says most pipe lining jobs take a single day, and that traditional sewer line replacement can take a week or more [14].

Can pipe bursting replace a cast iron or clay sewer line?

Usually. The EPA fact sheet says most existing pipe materials can be burst, though some ductile iron and reinforced concrete can be hard to burst [5]. Its project examples include bursting clay and cast iron sewer pipe [5].

Is the old pipe removed in pipe bursting?

Not in one piece. The bursting head pushes the old pipe outward until it breaks apart, and pulls the new pipe into the space it leaves [5]. With lining, the old pipe stays whole and becomes the host for the liner.

Definition Bank

Term Meaning
Pipe bursting Breaking the old pipe outward while pulling a new pipe into its place.
Cured in place pipe (CIPP) lining A resin-soaked liner cured hard inside the old pipe, forming a new pipe within it.
Host pipe The old pipe that stays in the ground around a liner.
High-density polyethylene (HDPE) The plastic pipe pulled in during bursting.
SDR Standard diameter ratio, the pipe’s outside diameter divided by its wall thickness. Philadelphia bursting uses SDR 17.
Nominal size The trade size of a pipe, such as 4 inch or 6 inch.
Building sewer The private pipe that carries waste from the building to the public sewer.
Building drain The lowest drain pipe inside the building, also called the house drain.
Sewer lateral The pipe that connects the house drain to the City sewer.
Back grade Pipe that slopes the wrong way, so waste does not drain.
Recorded video camera survey A recorded camera run through the pipe that L&I reviews before and after the work.
Design life The service life a pipe or liner is engineered for. It is not a warranty.
PA One Call Pennsylvania’s notice system that gets buried utilities marked before digging.

 

Entity Cards

Philadelphia Plumbing Code, Section P-716

Property Value
Covers Pipe bursting of building sewers and building drains
Size limit Gravity pipe 6 inches and smaller, same nominal size
Surveys Recorded survey before, second survey approved before pressure test
Source American Legal Publishing

 

Department of Licenses and Inspections (L&I)

Property Value
Role Issues the plumbing permit and reviews the camera surveys
Lining limit One and two family homes, gravity pipe 4 inches and larger
Source L&I FAQ PB_035

 

Philadelphia Water Department (PWD)

Property Value
Role Sewer Connection Permit for lateral repair
Owner responsibility Pipe from the house to the City sewer
Source PWD permits page; responsibility diagram, 03/2026

 

U.S. EPA retrospective CIPP study

Property Value
Samples 25 in-service liners, 11 cities, 5 to 34 years old
Finding Expected to last their 50-year design life and probably well beyond
Source Procedia Engineering, 2016

 

TEPPFA polyolefin sewer pipe study

Property Value
Finding At least 100 years for PE and PP gravity sewer pipe, when basic conditions are met
Evidence Pipe excavated after about 8 to 38 years
Source TEPPFA, December 2014

 

Ring The Bell Plumbing, Heating & Drains

Property Value
Role Camera inspection, CIPP lining, pipe bursting and excavation
License Philadelphia Master Plumber License #051593
Phone 267-804-1824
Source https://ringthebellplumbing.com/

 

Sources

  1.       City of Philadelphia, Philadelphia Plumbing Code, Section P-716, Replacement of building sewers and building drains by pipe-bursting methods (American Legal Publishing) (read November 3, 2026). https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-271040
  2.       International Code Council, CodeNotes: Replacement of Underground Building Sewers and Building Drains in the I-Codes, 2021 IPC Section 716, 2022 (2022). https://www.iccsafe.org/wp-content/uploads/22-22037_PMG_CodesNotes_Undergrnd_Sewers_Drains_FINAL.pdf
  3.       City of Philadelphia, Department of Licenses and Inspections, FAQ: Significant changes between the 2018 and 2021 Philadelphia Plumbing Code, PB_035, file posted September 2025 (file posted September 2025). https://www.phila.gov/media/20250918152438/PB_035_FAQ_2021-IPC-Significant-Changes-FAQ-Final.pdf
  4.       City of Philadelphia, Department of Licenses and Inspections, EZ Permit Standard: Plumbing, PB_030_F, 2026 (2026). https://www.phila.gov/media/20260622154348/PB_030_F-EZ-Plumbing-Permit-Standards-2026.pdf
  5.       U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Water Technology Fact Sheet: Pipe Bursting, EPA 832-F-06-030, September 2006 (September 2006). https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2019-08/documents/pipe_bursting_fact_sheet_p100il70.pdf
  6.       Procedia Engineering, Studying the Life-cycle Performance of Gravity Sewer Rehabilitation Liners in North America, 2016 (U.S. EPA retrospective study) (2016). https://aminer.org/pub/5ce2c4d1ced107d4c61a59ee/studying-the-life-cycle-performance-of-gravity-sewer-rehabilitation-liners-in-north
  7.       TEPPFA, 100 Year Service Life of Polypropylene and Polyethylene Gravity Sewer Pipes, full technical report, Revision 2, December 2014 (December 2014). https://conduitcalc.plasticpipe.org/pdf/tepffa-european-plastic-pipe-fittings-association.pdf
  8.       Angi, How Much Does Sewer Line Replacement Cost? 2026 Data (2026 data). https://www.angi.com/articles/how-much-does-sewer-line-replacement-or-repair-cost.htm
  9.       Bob Vila, How Much Does Sewer Line Replacement Cost?, updated January 27, 2023 (updated January 27, 2023). https://www.bobvila.com/articles/sewer-line-replacement-cost/
  10.   This Old House, How Much Does Sewer Line Replacement Cost? 2026 Pricing (2026 pricing). https://www.thisoldhouse.com/plumbing/sewer-line-replacement-cost
  11.   Angi, How Much Does Trenchless Sewer Line Replacement Cost in Philadelphia, PA? 2026 Data (2026 data). https://www.angi.com/articles/trenchless-sewer-line-replacement-cost/pa/philadelphia
  12.   Philadelphia Water Department, From Street to Sink: Water System Responsibility, 03/2026 (March 2026). https://water.phila.gov/wp-content/uploads/files/customer-responsibility-diagram.pdf
  13.   Philadelphia Water Department, Water & Sewer Permits (read November 3, 2026). https://water.phila.gov/development/connections/permits/
  14.   Angi, What Is a Trenchless Sewer Repair? (no date shown) (no date shown). https://www.angi.com/articles/trenchless-sewer-replacement-good-idea.htm